Honest Comparisons

What I Bought vs What I Should Have Bought

I research trillion-dollar GSE trades for a living but can't buy a decent phone charger. These are my actual Amazon purchases, the better alternatives I should have bought, and the self-deprecating stories behind each one.

16 comparisons • Updated regularly • Links are affiliate (details below)

🏄 Outdoor2026-02-16

The Beach Wagon That Cost Me Triple

$126.25→$39.99(8,432 reviews)

I ordered the $40 wagon. It got cancelled. I panic-bought a $126 wagon because my daughter needed it for the beach that weekend. Classic me.

Read the full story

💻 Tech2025-10-26

The Laptop Cooler I Bought to Save My Gaming Laptop

$27.81→$49.99(12,876 reviews)

I bought a $2,000 ASUS ROG gaming laptop and then cheaped out on the thing that keeps it alive. The Kootek works, barely. The IETS actually cools.

Read the full story

💪 Fitness2025-12-13

The $43 Sandals That Are Actually Worth It

$42.75→$54.95(5,234 reviews)

Plot twist: I actually got this one mostly right. OOFOS recovery sandals are legit. The Hoka is slightly better but the OOFOS at $43 is the move.

Read the full story

🩺 Health2025-10-15

Monitoring My Blood Pressure (From Reading Court Filings)

$38.22→$49.99(41,876 reviews)

I bought a blood pressure monitor after reading particularly stressful court filings. Got the Bronze. Should have spent $12 more for the Silver.

Read the full story

👶 Kids2025-12-14

The White Noise Machine That Runs Our Entire Household

$35.30→$44.99(68,432 reviews)

The Babelio 2-pack was a decent deal and they work. But the Yogasleep Dohm is an actual white noise machine, not a Bluetooth speaker playing loops. For a baby's room? Dohm wins.

Read the full story

🏠 Home2025-12-21

The Linen Duvet Cover (My One Bougie Purchase)

$109.13→$139.90(12,345 reviews)

For once I spent real money on something. The Shilucheng is solid linen for $109. But the Quince at $140 is the one the bedding subreddits actually recommend.

Read the full story

💻 Tech2025-09-03

The $15 Gaming Mouse vs. The One That Actually Works

$14.99→$39.99(87,654 reviews)

The Zelotes scroll wheel started scrolling on its own. The Logitech G502 has 87,000 reviews and a scroll wheel that respects your intentions.

Read the full story

👶 Kids2026-02-15

The Pocket Microscope That Made My Daughter a Scientist

$32.09→$49.99(15,432 reviews)

The pocket microscope is actually a great impulse buy for a little kid. But if you want something that'll last past the toddler phase, the National Geographic is the play.

Read the full story

🤷 Other2026-02-03

CATAN: The Only Investment That Always Pays Off

$47.07→$69.99(42,345 reviews)

CATAN is the best $47 I've ever spent. But I should have gotten the 5-6 player bundle for $70 because every game night someone asks 'can one more person play?'

Read the full story

🏠 Home2026-02-04

The $10 Spray That Saved My Security Deposit

$9.60→$14.97(42,567 reviews)

Miami + bathroom = mold situation. Moldex worked fine but the RMR-86 is the internet's mold-destroying weapon of choice with 42k reviews.

Read the full story

💻 Tech2025-01-30

The $2,000 Gaming Laptop (My Best and Worst Decision)

$1,899.99→$1,699.99(5,678 reviews)

I spent $2,000 on an ASUS ROG Strix, then another $200 on accessories to make it usable. The Lenovo Legion Pro 5 was $200 cheaper with better thermals out of the box.

Read the full story

🩺 Health2025-10-13

The Great Shampoo Experiment (Selsun Blue vs. Nizoral)

$8.47→$15.99(78,432 reviews)

I bought both. Selsun Blue is the brute force option. Nizoral is the smart play. I use Nizoral 2x/week and regular shampoo the rest of the time.

Read the full story

🩺 Health2025-10-21

The $7/Head Toothbrush Replacement Racket

$34.99→$19.99(12,345 reviews)

I pay $7 per toothbrush head because Oral-B has me locked in. The generics at $2.50 each are probably fine. This is the printer ink of dental care.

Read the full story

💻 Tech2025-01-30

The $20 USB-C Hub (Because My $2,000 Laptop Needs More Ports)

$19.99→$33.99(38,765 reviews)

I bought a USB hub from a company that doesn't exist on Google. The Anker with 38k reviews was $14 more. Pattern recognition is not my strength.

Read the full story

🏠 Home2026-01-05

The $11 Shower Curtain That Taught Me Nothing

$10.69→$10.69(87,654 reviews)

Plot twist: I actually bought the best-reviewed shower curtain on Amazon. 87,000 reviews. $11. Sometimes the cheapest option IS the best option.

Read the full story

🩺 Health2025-11-04

The $8 Sleep Gummies (Because Court Filings Keep Me Up)

$7.53→$9.99(52,345 reviews)

I take 5mg melatonin gummies that taste like candy. Research says 3mg time-release is better. But the gummies are $8 and I'm already asleep before I can research further.

Read the full story

Get Glen's Musings

Occasional thoughts on AI, Claude, investing, and building things. Free. No spam.

Unsubscribe anytime. I respect your inbox more than Congress respects property rights.

Affiliate Disclosure: Links on this page go to Amazon and include an affiliate tag. If you buy something, I earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only feature products I've actually purchased or researched. The comparisons are honest — I'm usually roasting myself for buying the worse option.

Want to see how I actually invest?

View Positions Fanniegate Billionaire Profiles