Tinder vs Reality
Gandalf on
Tinder
Grey. Wizard. 2,019 years young. Looking for someone who appreciates a good firework show. Not looking for anyone in a rush. He arrives precisely when he means to — forty-five minutes late. He speaks in riddles. He tells a story that doesn't finish by dessert. It is, somehow, the best date she's ever been on.
The Profile
What His Tinder Looks Like
Bio: "Gandalf. Grey (upgrading soon). 2,019 years young. I have seen the rise and fall of civilizations and I still cannot figure out this app. Looking for good conversation and someone who does not mind if I smoke a pipe."
The Photos
Photo 1: The Sunset
A breathtaking panoramic sunset over rolling green hills. Mountains in the distance. Golden light hitting the clouds. It looks like the screensaver of a computer owned by God. There is no person in this photo. Gandalf apparently believes the sunset speaks for itself. It does, honestly. She swiped right on a landscape photo.
Photo 2: The Fireworks
An incredible firework display over what appears to be a rural village. The fireworks are in the shape of a dragon. An actual, flight-capable, fire-breathing dragon made of light. No civilian fireworks company can do this. This is not a firework. This is a magical weapon that he is using recreationally. The caption says 'I bring the party.'
Photo 3: The Hat
Just the hat. A tall, pointed, grey hat photographed on a table next to a pipe and a mug of tea. No face. No person. Just a hat. It is the most iconic hat in the history of headwear. It communicates everything you need to know about this man: he is old, he is wise, and he will not be rushed into showing you his face before the time is right.
Photo 4: The Group Photo
Gandalf with eight shorter companions on what appears to be a hiking trip. They are standing on a mountain pass. Several of them look terrified. One of them is carrying a ring and appears to be having the worst day of his life. Gandalf is smiling serenely. He is the only one smiling. The caption says 'Weekend trip with friends.' It was not a weekend. It took eleven months.
Photo 5: The Bridge Photo
Gandalf standing dramatically on a narrow stone bridge, staff raised, facing something that is just out of frame. The lighting is incredible — orange and red, very dramatic. He appears to be yelling. His posture suggests he is having the most intense moment of his life. She will later learn he was telling a demon made of fire and shadow that it could not pass. The caption says 'Setting boundaries.'
The Prompts
I'm looking for...
"Someone who appreciates a good firework show. Not looking for: anyone in a rush. I arrive precisely when I mean to, and I mean to arrive when the moment calls for it. This applies to dinner reservations."
My simple pleasures...
"Pipe tobacco at sunset. A warm fire and old friends. Second breakfast. Elevenses. The laughter of hobbits. Defeating ancient evils. Tea."
The way to win me over is...
"Courage. Not the loud kind. The quiet kind. The kind where you do the right thing even when you are small and frightened and the world is dark. That’s the only thing I have ever been looking for."
A boundary I have...
"You shall not pass it."
The Main Event
What the Date Is Actually Like
A wizard arrives precisely when he means to. He means to arrive forty-five minutes late with a pipe, a pointy hat, and a two-hour story about elves.
7:00 PM — The Agreed Time
She is at the restaurant. It is a cozy place — candlelight, wooden tables, a fireplace. She chose it because his profile mentioned fireplaces and tea. He is not here. She is not surprised. His profile did say 'not looking for anyone in a rush.'
7:45 PM — The Arrival
Gandalf walks in exactly forty-five minutes late. He does not rush. He does not apologize. He does not acknowledge that forty-five minutes have passed. He walks in with the deliberate, measured pace of someone who has crossed entire continents on foot and considers the concept of 'late' to be a construct invented by people who have not lived for two millennia. He is wearing grey robes. Full grey robes. And the hat. He is wearing the hat indoors. He removes it and hangs it on the coat rack with the gravity of a man performing a sacred ritual. She asks, 'Were you stuck in traffic?' He says, 'A wizard is never late. Nor is he early. He arrives precisely when he means to.' She stares at him. He sits down. He orders tea.
7:50 PM — The Order
The waiter asks what he would like to drink. Gandalf says, 'Tea, please. The good kind.' The waiter asks what kind. Gandalf says, 'The kind that has been through something.' The waiter brings Earl Grey. Gandalf accepts it with a nod that suggests the waiter has passed a test. He also asks if they have pipe tobacco. They do not. He produces his own pipe and asks if he may smoke it. He may not. He places the unlit pipe on the table and looks at it sadly for the rest of the evening. He also orders toast and jam. Just toast and jam. She ordered a steak. He looks at her steak with no judgment and quiet incomprehension.
8:00 PM — The Riddles
She asks him what he does for work. He says, 'I help people find their courage.' She says, 'Like a life coach?' He stares meaningfully into the distance for ninety seconds. Ninety. Seconds. She counts. He then says, 'In a manner of speaking.' She asks where he lives. He says, 'I go where I am needed.' She asks if that means he is homeless. He chuckles warmly and says, 'Home is not a place, my dear. It is a feeling.' She asks a direct yes-or-no question: 'Do you have an apartment?' He says, 'I have walked in places where the stars themselves were young.' This is not an answer. She knows this is not an answer. She cannot stop finding him fascinating.
8:15 PM — The Story That Will Not End
She asks him to tell her about himself. This is a mistake. He begins a story. The story starts in the Second Age of Middle-earth. She does not know what the Second Age is. She does not know what Middle-earth is. She does not interrupt because his voice is the most soothing thing she has ever heard. The story involves elven kings, a dark lord, rings of power, a war that lasted centuries, and an eagle. By the time the appetizers arrive, they are in the Third Age. He has not asked for her name yet. The story includes dialogue. He does the voices. The voices are good. She has forgotten she ordered food.
8:45 PM — The Pause
Gandalf pauses mid-story to eat his toast. He eats toast the way other people attend a symphony. Slowly. Deliberately. With an awareness of every crumb. He butters it with precision. He applies jam in a pattern that suggests mathematical intent. She eats her steak. There is a long silence. It is not awkward. It is the least awkward silence she has ever experienced. He looks at the fireplace. She looks at the fireplace. They sit in silence for four full minutes and it feels like the most meaningful four minutes of her adult life. She does not understand what is happening.
9:00 PM — The Wisdom
She tells him about her job. She tells him she is thinking of quitting but she is scared. He puts down his tea. He looks at her with those ancient, knowing eyes. He says, 'All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given to us.' She was not prepared for this. She was not prepared for a man in a pointy hat to deliver the most emotionally devastating life advice she has ever received over toast and jam. Her eyes water. She pretends it is the fireplace smoke. There is no smoke. The fireplace is gas-powered. He knows she is pretending. He does not mention it.
9:20 PM — The Story Resumes
Gandalf resumes the story. They are now in the late Third Age. A creature called Gollum has become involved. The story has been going for over an hour and appears to be approximately fifteen percent complete. Their entrees are finished. He orders more tea. She orders a glass of wine. She has never been more invested in a story about fictional geology. He describes a volcanic mountain with the passion of a man who was there. He was there. She does not know this yet.
10:00 PM — Dessert and the Eagles
The story reaches what appears to be the climax. Everything is hopeless. Two small people are on a volcano. All seems lost. She is leaning forward. Her wine is untouched. Her dessert is untouched. 'And then?' she whispers. 'The eagles came,' he says. She exhales. She realizes she has been holding her breath. She has been emotionally invested in a story told by a first date for over ninety minutes. The waiter brings the check. Gandalf reaches into his robes and produces exact change. In coins. Ancient coins. She does not ask where the coins came from.
10:15 PM — The Goodbye
Gandalf walks her to her car. The night air is cool. He puts his hat back on. Under the streetlamp, he looks like a figure from a painting — tall, grey, gentle, impossibly old. He takes her hand. 'You will find your courage,' he says. 'You already have it. You simply haven’t needed it yet.' She wants to cry. She does not cry. He nods once, turns, and walks away into the night. He does not look back. She sits in her car for twelve minutes before starting the engine. She calls her best friend. 'How was the date?' her friend asks. 'He was forty-five minutes late, spoke in riddles, told a two-hour story about elves, and ate nothing but toast,' she says. 'It was the best date I’ve ever been on.' Her friend says, 'That makes no sense.' She says, 'I know.' She never sees him again. He shows up in her life four years later, at the exact moment she needs him, and says, 'I told you that you had courage.' She still cannot explain any of this.
He told a two-hour story about elves and ate nothing but toast.
It was the best date I've ever been on and I cannot explain a single thing about why.
Date Rating: 10/10
Forty-five minutes late. Spoke in riddles for an hour. Told a story about elves that started before dessert and did not finish. Ate nothing but toast and jam. Ordered tea with the seriousness of a man negotiating a peace treaty. Stared meaningfully into the distance on three separate occasions.
The best date she has ever been on. She cannot explain why. Nobody can. That's the magic.
Get Glen’s Updates
Investing insights, new tools, and whatever I’m building this week. Free. No spam.
Unsubscribe anytime. I respect your inbox more than Congress respects property rights.
More Disastrous Dates
Darth Vader on Tinder
The breathing is immediately noticeable. He can't eat through the mask.
Read moreShrek on Tinder
Every course is onion-based. Donkey keeps interrupting. Layers.
Read moreBatman on Tinder
Cancels 4 dates. Returns from the bathroom with bruises.
Read moreAll 11 Profiles
The complete collection. 0 second dates. 3 restraining orders.
Read more