#quest-planning
The Fellowship of the Ring
One channel to rule them all. One channel to find them. One channel where nobody reads the briefing and Boromir won't stop pitching the same bad idea.
47
Paragraph Briefing
0
People Who Read It
9
Companions
1
Ring
#quest-planning
9 membersChannel topic: "One does not simply walk into Mordor." — set by Aragorn
I have created this channel for a matter of utmost urgency. Strangers from distant lands, friends of old — you have been summoned to answer the threat of Mordor. Please read the briefing document pinned above before we begin.
Elrond set the channel topic to: "Decide the fate of the One Ring. NO side conversations."
Thank you, Elrond. I have prepared a comprehensive briefing on the history of the One Ring, the current threat from Sauron, the geopolitical landscape of Middle-earth, the strategic options available to us, the risks of each path, a SWOT analysis of the Fellowship concept, and a recommended course of action. It is 47 paragraphs. I recommend reading it in its entirety before forming opinions.
Can someone give me the TL;DR?
The TL;DR IS the briefing, Peregrin Took.
OK I skimmed it. Quick question: Why don't we just USE the ring? Hear me out — it's the most powerful weapon in Middle-earth. Gondor could use it to defend against Mordor. It's right there. We just... use it.
Boromir, if you had read paragraph 14 through 23 of my briefing, you would know exactly why that is a catastrophically bad idea.
I'm just saying, it's a powerful weapon and we're in a war. Is anyone else going to at least consider this?
7 replies (Aragorn: No. Legolas: No. Gimli: No. Elrond: Absolutely not. Gandalf: Read the briefing. Boromir: You're all making a mistake. Gandalf: PARAGRAPH 14.)
The ring must be destroyed. My elven eyes can see the darkness spreading from Mordor even now. The shadow grows.
Then what are we waiting for? I'll destroy it right now.
Gimli attempted to destroy the ring with an axe. The axe broke. The ring is fine.
The ring cannot be destroyed by any craft that we here possess. This was in paragraph 27 of Gandalf's briefing.
My axe...
Have you considered that this would not have happened if you had read the briefing?
Nobody asked you, elf.
12 replies (a passive-aggressive argument about dwarven craftsmanship vs elven wisdom that lasts 45 minutes and resolves nothing)
Sorry to interrupt but has anyone tried the tomatoes from the South Farthing this season? Absolutely magnificent. I brought some for the council meeting. Also taters. I always bring extra taters.
Sam, this is a channel about the fate of Middle-earth.
Right, sorry. But you should try the taters. Po-tay-toes. Boil em, mash em, stick em in a stew.
The ring must go to Mount Doom. It is the only way. I have spent 60 years in the wilderness preparing for this moment and I can guide whoever carries it.
Who made you the leader? You're literally a homeless ranger.
He is Aragorn, son of Arathorn. You owe him your allegiance.
Gondor has no king. Gondor needs no king.
Can we PLEASE get back on topic? We need to decide who carries the ring. This has been a 25-minute meeting and we've accomplished nothing. This is worse than the Last Alliance.
I still think we should use the ring.
BOROMIR.
I will take the Ring to Mordor.
Though... I do not know the way.
FINALLY. Meeting adjourned. I will help you bear this burden, Frodo Baggins.
You have my sword.
And you have my bow.
AND MY AXE!
Fine. I'll come too. But I still think we should use the ring.
1 reply (Gandalf: Boromir I am going to mute you.)
Mr. Frodo isn't going anywhere without me!
We're coming too!
Yeah! Wait, where are we going?
Nine companions. So be it. You shall be the Fellowship of the Ring.
Great. What about second breakfast?
Aragorn changed the channel topic to: "One does not simply walk into Mordor."
DID YOU JUST CHANGE THE TOPIC TO MOCK ME?
I don't know what you mean.
Pippin used @channel in #quest-planning
@channel Does anyone else hear that weird noise outside? I think it might be a Nazgul. Or maybe a cat. Hard to tell.
Peregrin Took. It is THREE IN THE MORNING. You do NOT @channel for a cat. I swear on the Valar, if you touch a Palantir next, I will send you home.
Pip, we talked about this. No @channel after midnight.
I do not sleep, so this does not bother me. But for the record, it was a cat.
SOME OF US NEED SLEEP, ELF. Not all of us can stand around looking pretty with our eyes open all night.
4 replies (Legolas: That is literally what elves do. Gimli: I know and I hate it. Legolas: You are welcome to try. Gimli: I am going back to sleep. Goodnight.)
Since we're all awake, anyone want some leftover stew? I made extra.
I can't sleep anyway. The ring keeps whispering. It's like a group notification I can't mute.
If you're not using the ring, I could hold it for a while. Just to give you a break. Just for a bit.
Boromir, go to sleep.
Good morning. I see from the message history that this fellowship is already falling apart and you haven't even left Rivendell yet. I have lived 6,000 years and I have never seen a project go off the rails this fast.
I'm starting to think we should have just done an email.
"One does not simply walk into Mordor. But one does simply @channel at 3 AM about a cat."
— Pippin, probably
Get Glen's Musings
Occasional thoughts on AI, Claude, investing, and building things. Free. No spam.
Unsubscribe anytime. I respect your inbox more than Congress respects property rights.
Keep Exploring
All Movie Slack Channels
11 iconic movie scenes reimagined as workplace Slack channels.
Read more#death-star-ops
The Battle of Yavin. Tarkin ignores the exhaust port warning.
Read more#avengers-initiative
The Battle of New York. Cap can't figure out Slack.
Read moreGlen Bradford's Blog
2,700+ posts on investing, Fanniegate, and life.
Read more