Why It Ranks
The Nice Guys proved Ryan Gosling is one of the great physical comedians of his generation. Shane Black's screenplay is the sharpest of the decade. The 70s noir atmosphere is impeccable. It flopped theatrically because the world does not deserve nice things, but its cult grows annually.
The Film
The Nice Guys is the best buddy comedy of the 2010s — a 1970s Los Angeles noir about a private detective and a hired enforcer investigating a missing girl, which spirals into a conspiracy involving the auto industry, the porn industry, and the Department of Justice. Shane Black, who invented the buddy action comedy with Lethal Weapon, returned to the genre and produced his finest work since Kiss Kiss Bang Bang.
Ryan Gosling's revelation as a physical comedian is the film's secret weapon. His Holland March is a cowardly, alcoholic, incompetent detective whose screams of terror — particularly the bathroom stall scene — are the funniest sounds any dramatic actor has ever produced. Russell Crowe's Jackson Healy is the muscle with a heart of gold, and their chemistry is instant and effortless. Angourie Rice, as March's precocious daughter Holly, steals every scene she is in.
The 1970s setting allows Black to satirize an era when the American auto industry was actively suppressing environmental regulation — a conspiracy so absurd it happens to be true. The film bombed at the box office because Warner Bros. did not know how to market an R-rated original buddy comedy in the franchise era. Its cult following has grown every year since, and it remains one of the great injustices of modern cinema that we never got a sequel.
Fun Facts
Ryan Gosling's scream in the bathroom stall was improvised — Russell Crowe's startled reaction is genuine.
Shane Black wrote the script in the early 2000s but could not get it made for over a decade.
The film's depiction of the 1970s auto industry conspiracy is based on real events — the catalytic converter was genuinely opposed by Detroit.
Gosling prepared for the role by watching 1970s detective shows and practicing physical comedy routines for weeks.
Get Glen's Musings
Occasional thoughts on AI, Claude, investing, and building things. Free. No spam.
Unsubscribe anytime. I respect your inbox more than Congress respects property rights.
Keep Exploring
Top 25 Comedies
See the full ranked list of the funniest films ever made.
Read moreTop 25 Action Movies
The greatest action films ever made, ranked.
Read moreTop 25 Sci-Fi Movies
The greatest science fiction films ever made, ranked.
Read moreTop 25 Sports Movies
Rocky, Hoosiers, Rudy — the greatest sports films ranked.
Read moreConsulting
Salesforce development and technical consulting.
Read moreWins
Track record of wins across investing, building, and creating.
Read more