Read the screenplay: FANNIEGATE — $7 trillion. 17 years. The biggest fraud in American capital markets.
OrganizationGSE / HousingShareholder Rights
IU

Investors Unite

The coalition fighting for GSE shareholder rights — founded by Tim Pagliara, powered by conviction.

The Story

In September 2008, the U.S. government placed Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into conservatorship. The stated purpose was to stabilize the housing market during the financial crisis. Treasury injected capital and took a senior preferred position, but the existing shareholders — hundreds of thousands of individuals, pension funds, community banks, and institutional investors — were told their investments would be protected. The conservatorship was supposed to be temporary.

Then came August 2012. The government executed the Third Amendment to the Preferred Stock Purchase Agreements — the so-called “Net Worth Sweep.” Instead of the fixed 10% dividend Treasury had been receiving, the new terms swept every dollar of GSE profit directly to the government. In perpetuity. Shareholders would never receive another dividend. The value of their preferred and common shares was effectively zeroed out — not because the companies failed, but because the government decided to keep everything.

This is where Investors Unite comes in. Tim Pagliara, the CEO of CapWealth Advisors in Nashville, saw what was happening and refused to accept it. Individual shareholders had no power against the federal government acting alone. But together — organized, funded, and focused — they could fight. Tim founded Investors Unite as a coalition to give GSE shareholders a collective voice: to coordinate legal strategy, engage Congress, file amicus briefs, and make the case that the Net Worth Sweep was an unconstitutional taking of private property.

The coalition grew to over 2,000 members. They didn't just file lawsuits — they testified before Congress, wrote hundreds of articles, built media relationships, and kept the issue alive year after year when the establishment wanted everyone to move on. Investors Unite became the organizational backbone of the GSE shareholder rights movement.

Timeline

September 2008

Conservatorship Begins

The U.S. government places Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac into conservatorship under the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA). Treasury injects capital through Senior Preferred Stock Purchase Agreements, taking a senior position above all existing shareholders. At the time, the government promises this is temporary — a bridge to stability, not a permanent seizure.

August 2012

The Net Worth Sweep

Treasury and FHFA execute the Third Amendment to the PSPAs, replacing the fixed 10% dividend with a "net worth sweep" — every dollar of profit, in perpetuity, goes straight to Treasury. Shareholders get nothing. Ever. This is the moment that transforms a bailout into what shareholders call an illegal taking of private property. The GSEs are now profitable again, but shareholders will never see a cent.

2012 - 2013

Investors Unite Is Born

Tim Pagliara, CEO of CapWealth Advisors in Nashville, recognizes that individual shareholders have no voice against the federal government. He founds Investors Unite as a coalition to organize preferred and common shareholders, coordinate legal strategy, engage Congress, and make the case that the Net Worth Sweep violates the Fifth Amendment's Takings Clause. The coalition grows to over 2,000 members.

2013 - 2018

Legal Battles & Congressional Testimony

Multiple lawsuits are filed challenging the Net Worth Sweep. Investors Unite members testify before Congress, file amicus briefs, and write hundreds of articles making the case for shareholder rights. The coalition builds relationships with sympathetic lawmakers and keeps the issue alive when the media moves on. Cases like Perry Capital v. Mnuchin and Collins v. Yellen work through the courts.

June 2021

Collins v. Yellen — Supreme Court

The Supreme Court rules in Collins v. Yellen that FHFA's leadership structure was unconstitutional, but punts on the Net Worth Sweep itself. A partial victory — the fight continues. The coalition refuses to accept defeat and pushes for resolution through both the courts and the political process.

2021 - Present

The Fight Continues

Over a decade into the conservatorship, Investors Unite and its allies continue pressing for shareholder justice. New legal theories, new political opportunities, and the same unwavering conviction that what the government did was wrong. Treasury has collected over $300 billion from the GSEs — far exceeding the original bailout amount. The shareholders who funded the recovery have received nothing in return.

The Coalition

TP
Tim Pagliara

Founder, Investors Unite

CEO of CapWealth managing $2B in assets. Founded Investors Unite to give GSE shareholders a collective voice. The leader of the movement and Glen's all-time hero.

GB
Glen Bradford

Activist Investor & Writer

Ran Global Speculation LP. Wrote thousands of articles on the GSE saga. Organized grassroots shareholder advocacy for 12+ years. Built the media arm of the movement.

BM
Bill Maloni

Former Fannie Mae Senior VP

20+ years inside Fannie Mae at the senior executive level. Now the most prominent independent voice on GSE policy through the Maloni Blog. Institutional memory personified.

DF

David Fiderer

Investigative Journalist

Relentless researcher who dug into the documents, the timelines, and the contradictions. Exposed the government's shifting narratives with forensic precision. A truth machine.

TS

Todd Sullivan

Investor & Advocate

ValuePlays founder. Long-time GSE shareholder who brought investment community credibility and never stopped making the case for fair treatment of shareholders.

RK

Robert King

Shareholder Advocate

One of the most dedicated voices in the coalition. Showed up to every hearing, filed every comment letter, and kept the pressure on when others moved on.

RM

Ryan McParlan

Coalition Member

Part of the core group that stayed in the fight year after year. Contributed to legal strategy discussions and shareholder coordination efforts.

Why They Fight

The case for shareholder rights

The core argument is simple: the government bailed out Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac during a crisis, and the GSEs paid back every dollar — with interest. By the time the Net Worth Sweep was imposed in 2012, both companies were returning to profitability. The sweep wasn't necessary to protect taxpayers. It was a decision to confiscate shareholder wealth because the government could.

Treasury has now collected over $300 billion from Fannie and Freddie — far exceeding the approximately $190 billion injected during the crisis. The shareholders who bore the risk, who held through the darkest days, who funded the companies' recovery through their capital — they received nothing. Zero dividends. Zero return of capital. Zero acknowledgment that their property rights exist.

This isn't just a financial dispute. It's a constitutional question. The Fifth Amendment says the government cannot take private property without just compensation. If the government can sweep every dollar of profit from a private company in perpetuity — after that company has repaid its obligations — then no shareholder's property rights are safe. What happened to GSE shareholders is a precedent that threatens every investor in every government-adjacent enterprise in America.

Investors Unite exists because someone had to stand up and say: this is wrong, and we're not going away until it's fixed. Twelve years later, they're still saying it.

Why It Matters

This is the defining fight of my investing life. I got into the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac saga in 2012 when I was running Global Speculation LP, my hedge fund. I was a Purdue-trained engineer who saw the Net Worth Sweep for exactly what it was: the government taking private property because nobody was powerful enough to stop them. I wrote about it. I organized around it. I connected with every person I could find who understood what was happening.

Tim Pagliara and Investors Unite gave all of us a home. A structure. A movement. Without Tim's leadership, the shareholder fight would have been a thousand individual voices shouting into the void. Instead, it became a coordinated campaign that testified before Congress, filed briefs at the Supreme Court, and forced the issue into the national conversation.

Twelve years in. Thousands of articles written. Hundreds of legal filings. Multiple trips to Washington. And we're still here. The crew — Tim, Bill Maloni, David Fiderer, Todd Sullivan, Robert King, Ryan McParlan, HV Patel, and so many others — never gave up. That's what Investors Unite represents: the conviction that if you know something is wrong, you fight until it's right. No matter how long it takes.

Get Glen's Musings

Occasional thoughts on AI, Claude, investing, and building things. Free. No spam.

Unsubscribe anytime. I respect your inbox more than Congress respects property rights.

Keep Exploring